The Best Skid Steers: Power, Versatility, and Value
When it comes to getting tough jobs done, skid steers are a real workhorse. These machines are super compact, really flexible, and great at handling all sorts of tasks. They're often cheaper to buy upfront than compact track loaders and simpler to keep up, especially since their wheels don't need the same kind of care as tracks. They're perfect for hard surfaces like concrete or asphalt, and they work best in places where you want to avoid extra wear on the ground—think city construction, paved areas, or delicate landscaping. This article, "The Best Skid Steers: Power, Versatility, and Value," breaks down the top options out there.
Key Takeaways
- Bobcat leads the market with a 40% share; they basically invented the skid steer.
- JCB offers great value, keeping about 58% of its worth after three years.
- Choosing the right skid steer means looking at things like how much it can lift and how reliable it is.
- Radial lift skid steers are good for things like backfilling and moving materials onto flatbed trucks.
- Vertical lift models are better for lifting heavy stuff straight up, like pallets or dumping into trucks.
1. Bobcat
Bobcat is pretty much the name people think of when they think of skid steers, and for good reason. They were the first to really make them, way back in the 60s, and they've been improving ever since. Their R-series CTLs are top-notch. They're built to be comfy, easy to use, and strong.
Bobcat offers a bunch of different sizes, from small to large, so you can find one that fits your needs. They make loaders with operating capacities from 1,400 lbs all the way up to 3,650 lbs, but the sweet spot seems to be between 2,000 lbs and 3,200 lbs. Plus, they make a ton of attachments, so you can do just about anything with a Bobcat.
Here's why Bobcat is a solid choice:
- Everyone knows the name.
- Lots of dealers for parts and service.
- Easy controls, so it doesn't take forever to learn how to use one.
- Cool features like touch screens and strong hydraulics.
Bobcat machines usually need service every 50 hours, with bigger maintenance at 500 hours. The newer M-Series are easier to service, which is a nice bonus.
Bobcats might cost a bit more upfront, like 10-15% more than some others, but they hold their value and get rented out a lot, so they're a good investment in the long run.
2. Caterpillar
Caterpillar holds a significant portion of the skid steer market, around 18-20%. They've built a strong presence by leveraging their reputation as a premium brand in heavy construction. It's interesting to note that Caterpillar entered the skid steer market relatively late, in 1999, but they quickly established themselves as a premium option, drawing on their century of construction equipment expertise.
Caterpillar skid steers are known for their durability and reliability.
Here are a few key models that are popular for rental businesses:
- 226D3 (Compact): This entry-level model has 67.1 HP and a 1,550 lb rated operating capacity. It's known for its maneuverability while maintaining the Cat reputation for durability. compact construction machine is designed to perform in tough conditions.
- 262D3 (Mid-Size): This versatile model offers 74.3 HP and a 2,700 lb operating capacity. It's ideal for diverse rental applications, from landscaping to construction.
- 272D3 (Large): This flagship model boasts 98 HP and a 3,700 lb operating capacity. It's designed for heavy-duty applications and can run virtually any attachment.
Caterpillar skid steers offer several advantages for rental businesses:
- High customer recognition and demand.
- Extensive dealer network for parts and service.
- User-friendly controls that require minimal training for renters.
- Advanced features like touch displays, best-in-class lift capacity, and strong hydraulics systems.
Caterpillar equipment features easy service access with rear-tilting cabs and grouped service points. The D3 series machines require 500-hour service intervals with daily fluid checks, reducing downtime compared to some competitors.
Caterpillar skid steers command a higher initial investment, typically 15-20% more than competitors. However, they offer strong residual values, usually retaining 60-65% of their value after three years. This premium positioning also allows for higher rental rates in most markets.
3. JCB
JCB's skid steers are known for their innovative design and focus on operator safety. The 270 model stands out as a popular choice, offering a blend of power and maneuverability suitable for various tasks, from construction to agriculture. One of the most distinctive features of JCB's skid steers is their single-arm design, which enhances visibility and simplifies maintenance compared to traditional double-arm loaders.
JCB's commitment to operator experience is evident in features like the side-door entry, which provides a safer and more convenient way to enter and exit the machine. This design eliminates the need to climb over attachments or under a raised boom, a significant advantage on long workdays.
Here are some key benefits of JCB skid steers:
- Enhanced visibility due to the single-arm design.
- Safer entry and exit with the side-door design.
- Simplified maintenance with ground-level service points.
4. Kubota
Kubota, primarily known for their tractors, has made a strong push into the construction equipment market with their skid steers. They've gained a reputation for reliability and fuel efficiency, making them a solid choice for many users. I've seen these machines on job sites more and more, and the operators seem pretty happy with them.
One thing that stands out is Kubota's focus on operator comfort. They understand that a comfortable operator is a more productive operator. Plus, they're often a bit more budget-friendly than some of the other big names, which is always a plus.
Kubota skid steers offer a compelling blend of performance and value, making them a smart choice for those looking to maximize their investment without sacrificing quality or capability.
Kubota offers a few key models that are worth checking out:
- SSV65: This model is a workhorse with a 64 HP engine and a 1,950 lb operating capacity. It's a great all-around machine for various tasks.
- SSV75: Stepping up in power, the SSV75 boasts 74.3 HP and a 2,300 lb capacity. It also features a wider cab for improved operator comfort. The Kubota SSV75 is a popular choice.
- Kubota also offers features like KubotaNOW, which helps you track machine vitals and manage maintenance. This can be a real time-saver and help prevent costly downtime.
Here's a quick look at some of the advantages Kubota brings to the table:
- Lower initial cost compared to some premium brands.
- Excellent fuel efficiency, potentially saving you money on operating costs.
- A growing dealer network, making parts and service more accessible.
5. CASE
CASE skid steers are definitely in the running when you're talking about tough machines. I've seen these things take a beating and keep on going. They've got a solid reputation, and for good reason. They're not always the flashiest, but they get the job done.
One thing I appreciate about CASE is their focus on operator comfort. Long days in a skid steer can be brutal, so having a comfortable cab makes a huge difference. Plus, they've made some smart choices about maintenance, which can save you a lot of headaches down the road.
CASE skid steers, particularly B-Series models, are designed for easy maintenance with tilt-up cabs, grouped service points, and extended 500-hour service intervals. That's a big deal when you're trying to keep your machine running smoothly.
Here's what I like about CASE:
- Strong performance: They've got the power you need for most jobs.
- Good operator comfort: Makes those long days a little easier.
- Easy maintenance: Less downtime means more productivity.
If you're looking for a reliable skid steer that can handle tough conditions, CASE is worth checking out. They might not be the cheapest option, but they offer a good balance of performance and durability. Consider the CASE skid steer models for your next purchase.
6. Gehl
Gehl is one of the original skid steer manufacturers, and they still have a loyal following, especially with experienced operators and in rural areas. They might not be the flashiest brand, but they're known for making solid, reliable machines. Gehl's compact track loaders are perfect for small jobs.
Gehl's appeal lies in its straightforward design and competitive pricing, making it a practical choice for those who value function over frills.
Here's a quick look at some popular models:
- R190: A 69 HP machine with a 1,900 lb operating capacity. It's a good all-around choice for general rental use.
- 324G (Mid-Size): This one has a 74 HP engine and a 2,690 lb rated capacity. It's got a good power-to-weight ratio, making it versatile.
- 332G (Large): This is the big boy, with 100 HP and a 3,600 lb operating capacity. It's best for heavy lifting and excavation.
Gehl Skid Steers:
- Offer exceptional hydraulic performance.
- Have vertical lift models that provide excellent reach at full height.
- Are compatible with many attachments.
One thing to keep in mind is that Gehl's dealer network isn't as extensive as some of the bigger brands. This can sometimes make finding parts a bit of a challenge, which could lead to longer downtime if something breaks. However, their competitive pricing and robust design make them a strong contender, especially if you're not in a rush for parts.
7. John Deere
John Deere, while famous for tractors, also makes some pretty solid skid steers. They hold about 12% of the skid steer market, which is a good chunk. Their experience with hydraulic systems really shines through in their construction equipment.
John Deere skid steers are known for being reliable and easy to maintain. They've got a good reputation, especially if you're already familiar with their agricultural equipment. Plus, they make a ton of attachments, so you can really customize your machine for whatever job you're doing.
John Deere skid steers are a solid choice if you need something dependable and versatile. They might cost a bit more upfront, but they hold their value well, and the strong dealer network is a definite plus, especially if you're in a rural area.
Here are a few popular models:
- 318G (Compact): Great for landscaping and smaller jobs.
- 324G (Mid-Size): A good all-around machine for rental fleets.
- 332G (Large): Perfect for heavy lifting and serious excavation.
8. New Holland
New Holland skid steers offer a compelling mix of value and performance, particularly for agricultural applications. They're known for their Super Boom vertical lift design, which provides excellent reach and dump height. While they might not have the same brand recognition as some of the top-tier manufacturers in the construction world, they hold their own, especially in rural markets.
New Holland's L328 is a popular model, especially among farmers and ranch owners. Its compact size allows it to maneuver in tight spaces, making it ideal for working inside barns or around obstacles. The L328 also features an 8-inch LCD multifunction display with an integrated backup camera, offering several user functions. The enhanced high-flow hydraulics at 3,046 psi make it compatible with a wide range of attachments.
New Holland skid steers are often priced competitively, typically 7-12% below premium brands. This can make them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers who don't want to sacrifice performance. They also have a strong dealer presence in agricultural regions, ensuring good parts availability through the CNH dealer network.
However, one common criticism is the operator's low seating position, which can lead to poor visibility of the bucket's cutting edge. Despite this, New Holland continues to innovate, implementing anti-vibration systems in their new models for a more comfortable ride.
Here are a few reasons why New Holland is a solid choice:
- Competitive pricing
- Strong dealer network
- Super Boom vertical lift design
9. Melroe Manufacturing
Melroe Manufacturing, now largely recognized as Bobcat, holds a special place in the history of skid steers. While the name might not be as prominent today, its legacy is undeniable. The company essentially pioneered the skid steer concept, forever changing the landscape of construction and agriculture.
Before the Bobcat name became synonymous with skid steers, it was Melroe Manufacturing that took a chance on the Keller brothers' invention. The partnership proved to be a game-changer. It's interesting to think about how different things might be if Melroe hadn't seen the potential in that early design. They really helped to bring the original Bobcat loader to the masses.
It's easy to forget the origins of iconic brands. Melroe's contribution is a reminder that innovation often comes from unexpected places and through collaborative efforts.
- Early adoption of the Keller brothers' design.
- Pioneering the skid steer concept.
- Laying the groundwork for Bobcat's future success.
10. Thompson Tractor
Thompson Tractor might not be a name everyone immediately associates with skid steers, but they're a significant player, especially in the Southeast. They primarily operate as a dealer for Caterpillar, so when you're looking at Thompson Tractor, you're essentially looking at Caterpillar equipment through a regional distributor.
Thompson Tractor's strength lies in its extensive support network and customer service. They offer a wide range of services, from sales and rentals to parts and maintenance, making them a one-stop shop for many businesses.
Thompson Tractor's deep roots in the region and commitment to customer satisfaction make them a reliable partner for businesses that rely on Caterpillar equipment. Their focus on building long-term relationships sets them apart from some of the larger, more impersonal dealerships.
Here's what makes them stand out:
- Strong regional presence: They have multiple locations across Alabama and Northwest Florida, ensuring convenient access to equipment and support.
- Extensive parts inventory: Minimizing downtime is crucial, and Thompson Tractor maintains a large inventory of parts to keep your machines running.
- Experienced service technicians: Their technicians are trained to handle all types of repairs and maintenance on Caterpillar equipment.
Wrapping It Up
So, we've gone through a lot about skid steers. It's pretty clear there's no single "best" one for everyone. What works for one person might not be right for another. It really comes down to what you need it for, how much you want to spend, and what kind of work you'll be doing. Thinking about things like lift capacity, how easy it is to fix, and if parts are easy to find can help a lot. Take your time, look at what's out there, and pick the one that makes the most sense for you. Happy digging!
Frequently Asked Questions
Which skid steer gives you the most bang for your buck?
The best skid steer for your money depends on what you need it for. As of 2025, JCB is often seen as a top choice. Their machines hold their value well, losing only about 42% after three years. They also have a special side-entry design that makes them safer and cheaper to fix, saving about 25% on maintenance. JCB skid steers have plenty of power for most jobs, and their controls are easy to use. CASE is another good option, as their machines cost less upfront (5-10% less than others) but still work just as well.
What's the top skid steer brand out there?
Choosing the right skid steer means thinking about what you'll use it for. Bobcat and Caterpillar are very popular and hold their value well. Bobcat has been around the longest and makes up 40% of the market. They have many sizes, from small ones for yard work to big ones for construction. Caterpillar also has a wide range of machines. Both are easy to fix and don't break down often, but they can be more expensive. For rental businesses, Bobcat and Caterpillar are good because many people ask for them by name. But if you're in a rural area or work with farms, John Deere or New Holland might be a better fit.
Why are skid steers a good choice for jobs?
Skid steers are great because they are small, can do many different jobs, and are good for lots of tasks. They are usually cheaper to buy than compact track loaders and easier to take care of because their wheels don't need as much work as tracks. They work best on hard surfaces like concrete or asphalt and are good when you don't want to damage the ground, like in city building projects or landscaping.
What does 'lift capacity' mean for a skid steer?
Lift capacity is how much weight a skid steer can pick up. There are two main types of lifts: radial and vertical. Vertical lifts move straight up and down, which is best for lifting heavy things like pallets or dumping stuff into trucks. Radial lifts move in an arc, which is good for spreading dirt or loading materials onto flatbed trucks because they have a longer reach. For rental companies, it's smart to have both kinds of skid steers. Vertical lift models often rent for more money and are good for loading and moving materials.
How do I pick a skid steer based on what I need it to do?
When picking a skid steer, think about what attachments you'll use. If you need to power tools that move a lot, like cold planers or stump grinders, you'll want a machine with strong hydraulic flow. If you're lifting heavy items or using snow blowers, you'll need a large skid steer with good lift capacity. For tough jobs that cause a lot of shaking, like using mulchers or rock saws, a large radial lift machine is better because it's simpler and less likely to get damaged.
What kinds of jobs are skid steers good for?
Skid steers can handle many different tasks. For pushing and leveling dirt, you'll want a powerful machine with good reach. For filling in holes, radial lift skid steers are good because they offer better visibility and reach. For moving lots of materials like rocks, dirt, or sand, a bigger or heavier skid steer is usually best.
